What should anatomists in 2010 do with an atlas that is both scientifically valuable and morally tainted. He said that the idea of national socialism must permeate education and science and that freedom in the liberal sense leads to chaos, which could not be permitted in science 4. Eduard pernkopf s atlas of topographical and applied human anatomy is a fourvolume anatomical atlas published between 1937 and 1963, and it is generally believed to be the most comprehensive. Plus, free twoday shipping for six months when you sign up for amazon prime for students. He is best known for his sevenvolume anatomical atlas, topographische anatomie des menschen translated as atlas of topographical and applied human anatomy. The majority of the illustrations in this atlas are truly works of art, demonstrating by their clarity and precision the best in collaboration between master medical artists and skillful anatomic prosectors. In april, 1933, he succeeded ferdinand hochstetter 18611954 as director of the anatomical institute. Ethics and access to teaching materials in the medical. The book was a 20year project of a prominent nazi and doctor, eduard pernkopf, who rose through the academic ranks in austria thanks to his support for adolf hitlers party. This classic among atlases of anatomy is derived from eduard pernkopf s 18881955 sevenvolume textbook, topographische anatomie des menschen. As a student he had worked under ferdinand hochstetter, director of the universitys anatomy efuard. We share interests our profession, politics, history, and religion.
The pernkopf anatomy atlas was compiled in austria during the nazi era 1938 to 1945 by eduard pernkopf, professor of anatomy and director of the anatomy institute at the university of vienna. How the pernkopf controversy facilitated a historical and ethical. Nerve surgeons assessment of the role of eduard pernkopfs. Jul 16, 2010 anatomya university of vienna investigation determined in 1998 that eduard pernkopf s anatomy department used bodies of executed prisoners from the gestapo and from viennas assize court to produce the illustrations in his topographical anatomy of man. Aware of the historical facts, 69% were comfortable using the atlas, 15% uncomfortable, and 17% undecided. He worked by himself while pernkopf resumed his prewar schedule despite the privations he had endured. The history of eduard pernkopfs topographische anatomie des.
Eduard pernkopf november 24, april 17, was an austrian professor of anatomy who later served as rector of the university of viennahis alma mater. Eduard pernkopf author of atlas of topographical and applied. In 2002 he was awarded the erwin schrodinger fellowship. Medical students assessment of eduard pernkopfs atlas. However, in the late 1980s, i came across essays by gerald weissman, an austrian born us physicianscientist at new york university, and david. Eduard pernkopf is the author of atlas of topographical and applied human anatomy, vol. We recently found that our library contained an anatomy atlas written by a nazi, 1 brought to our attention after reading of ernsts reference to it in his account of events at the university of vienna in 1938. It is a thing of wonder, a breathtaking book that maps the human body in elaborate detail and vivid brushstrokes. Global impact on science, education, and culture proof, if proof were needed, of the wide range of applications, durability, and global impact of plastination is amply demonstrated in this issue of the journal of plastination. Zlibrary is one of the largest online libraries in the world that contains over 4,960,000 books and 77,100,000 articles. By eduard pernkopf and edited by helmut ferner baltimore, urban g. A leading austrofascist, pernkopf was appointed dean of the vienna faculty of medicine shortly after the anschluss. He earned a phd degree from the university of leoben, austria, in 2002.
The morbid history of the nazis banned anatomy book gq. Download atlante di anatomia ebook free in pdf and epub format. The history of eduard pernkopf s topographische anatomie des menschen. When medical information comes from nazi atrocities the bmj.
Commentary on first hand accounts of events in the. Since vienna universitys 199798 inquiry into the background of eduard pernkopfs anatomical atlas, german and austrian anatomical institutes have been forced to confront their past, particularly the widespread procurement of bodies of victims of national socialism. Eduard manufacturer of photo etched and additional accessories. The legacy of academic medicine and human exploitation in the. To make it worse, pernkopf and his chief collaborators were all committed nazis, to the. He died suddenly of a stroke while working on the first book of the fourth volume. Atlas of topographical and applied human anatomy, vol. A noted anatomist, eduard pernkopf was the director of the institute of anatomy of the university of vienna and the founding editor of a landmark atlas of human anatomy that continues to be published in his name. Pernkopfs life and mind an obituary written by his student and postwar successor, as director of the second anatomy institute in vienna, hayek 1955, sums up eduard pernkopfs life. The life of eduard pernkopf was recounted by williams 1. Eduard pernkopf november 24, 1888 april 17, 1955 was an austrian professor of anatomy who later served as rector of the university of vienna, his alma mater. Pernkopf was habilitated for anatomy in 1921, becoming professor extraordinary in 1926, and in may, 1928, he became professor of anatomy at the university of vienna. To date, there has been no study examining the perceptions of firstyear medical students regarding eduard pernkopfs atlas, particularly during their study of gross anatomy and prior to coursework in medical ethics. Purchase access subscribe to jn learning for one year.
Letter to the editor commentary on first hand accounts of events in the laboratory of prof. A recommendation for the continued use of the pernkopf atlas sabine hildebrandt division of anatomical sciences, of. Pernkopf was born on november 24, 1888, in a small vil based on a presentation at ethics education in medical schools. Pdf eduard pernkopfs topographical anatomy of man has been a widely used standard work of anatomy for over sixty years. Already as a child his great interest was music, but his father died in 1903, and in order to help support his family he decided on a medical career. Eduard pernkopf was the son of a practicing physician and the youngest of three children. Our department of surgery has the responsibility for teaching anatomy and so has some. Sabinet revisiting the infamous pernkopf anatomy atlas. The surgeon had a dilemma only a nazi medical text could resolve.
Aug 01, 2019 atlas pernkopf pdf for more than 2 decades beginning in, university of vienna anatomist eduard pernkopf labored on his anatomical atlas, which he published as the. More than a slippery slope on march 12, 1938, nazi germany annexed austria. We thank the authors of the letter that was written about our article. Eduard photo etched and additional accessories scalemodel. A university of vienna investigation determined in that eduard pernkopf s anatomy department used bodies of executed prisoners from the gestapo and. Pdf how the pernkopf controversy facilitated a historical. Publication date 1980 topics human anatomy, topographical anatomy collection opensource language english. Knowledge of anatomy is essential to our practice the art of surgery.
Pernkopf was a fervent believer in national socialism. Eduard pernkopfs atlas of topographical and applied human anatomy is a fourvolume anatomical atlas published between 1937 and 1963, and it is generally believed to be the most comprehensive. Eduard pernkopf atlas of topographical and applied human anatomy in 2 volumes by eduard pernkopf atlas of topographical and applied human anatomy in 2 volumes 1964 jan 1, 1964 2. Jan 23, 2020 for several years, i knew the pernkopf atlas named after its author, eduard pernkopf, chair of anatomy and president of the university of vienna only as a unique and valued piece of science and art. The goal of clinical anatomy is to provide a medium for the exchange of current information between anatomists and clinicians. As a pernkopf anatomy he had worked under ferdinand hochstetter, director pernkopf anatomy the universitys anahomy institute. Rabbi joseph polak said that while the work was derived from real evil, it is used in the service of good. Read atlante di anatomia online, read in mobile or kindle. You are not supposed to look at pernkopf s anatomy. We are glad to see that the authors of the paper nerve surgeons assessment of the role of eduard pernkopfs atlas of topographic and applied human anatomy in surgical practice 1 reference the vienna protocol to which we contributed the section on jewish law for what to do when jewish holocaust era remains are discovered. Eduard pernkopf and the ethics of science from holocausts. Clinical anatomy is the official journal of the american association of clinical anatomists and the british association of clinical anatomists. Medical information from nazi atrocities transgresses the. Three days later, the ardent, outspoken nazi, eduard pernkopf, who at the time was professor of anatomy at the vienna medical school and the director of the vienna anatomy institute, became dean of the vienna medical school.
Nazi victims on the dissection table the anatomical. How the pernkopf controversy facilitated a historical and. An anatomical plate comparison between netters and pernkopf s atlases was performed to compare anatomical accuracy and surgical utility. Atlas pernkopf pdf for more than 2 decades beginning in, university of vienna anatomist eduard pernkopf labored on his anatomical atlas, which he published as the. Oct 22, 2018 pernkopf anatomy atlas, pernkopf instructed them to paint the organs they saw in as much detail as possible, to make them look like living tissue in print. One particular work with deep ethical implications is eduard pernkopfs 18881955 anatomical atlas, topographische anatomie des menschen atlas, which is a series of richly illustrated anatomical works that are infamous for the inclusion of nazi holocaust victims depicted among its anatomical subjects 1, 2. The following biography is mainly based on the article the history of eduard pernkopf s topographische anatomie des menschen see bibliography by david. In the uk there were, at that time, heightened sensibilities following the revelations of unlawful retention of thousands of.
1136 230 1149 167 1104 1483 1061 1588 1206 1020 1575 905 1614 1071 431 52 907 321 796 933 339 1667 1490 34 516 1581 893 1301 89 1209 247 495 1495 53